5 min read Investment Learning

What is Monte Carlo Simulation?

What is Monte Carlo Simulation?
Photo by Md Mahdi / Unsplash

Understanding the true value of a company like Tesla (TSLA) requires more than a single point estimate. Its growth trajectory, market position, and operational efficiency are subject to significant variables. This is where a Monte Carlo simulation becomes invaluable. It allows us to model the inherent uncertainty in key drivers, such as TSLA Monte Carlo deliveries and margin scenarios, providing a probabilistic range for the company's intrinsic value rather than a single, potentially misleading, figure.

What is Monte Carlo Simulation?

A Monte Carlo simulation is a computerised mathematical technique. It models the probability of different outcomes in a process that cannot easily be predicted due to random variables. Essentially, it runs thousands or millions of scenarios. Each scenario uses different random inputs drawn from defined probability distributions. This generates a distribution of possible outcomes, offering a more robust understanding of risk and potential returns.

Why Use Monte Carlo for Tesla (TSLA) Stock Analysis?

Tesla operates in a dynamic, capital-intensive industry. Its future performance hinges on several highly uncertain factors:

  • Deliveries Growth: How many vehicles will Tesla produce and sell globally? This depends on factory ramp-ups, demand, competition, and economic conditions.
  • Average Selling Price (ASP): Will prices hold, or will competition and market saturation force reductions?
  • Gross Margins: Can Tesla maintain or improve its margins amidst cost pressures, new product launches, and pricing strategies?
  • Operating Expenses: How efficiently will the company manage its research, development, and selling costs as it scales?
  • Capital Expenditure: How much investment is needed for new factories, technologies, and infrastructure?

Traditional discounted cash flow (DCF) models often use single-point estimates for these variables. This approach can be brittle. If one key assumption is slightly off, the resulting intrinsic value can be significantly skewed. Monte Carlo addresses this by treating each uncertain input as a range of possibilities, reflecting the real-world complexity.

Key Inputs for TSLA Monte Carlo Deliveries and Margin Scenarios

To perform a Monte Carlo simulation for Tesla, we need to define probability distributions for the most impactful variables within a DCF calculator. Screenwich provides a framework for this, allowing users to explore different assumptions. You can find detailed financial data and valuation tools for Tesla on Screenwich's TSLA page.

Modelling Deliveries Growth

Tesla's revenue is primarily driven by vehicle deliveries. Instead of assuming a fixed 20% annual growth, we might define a distribution:

  • Pessimistic: 15% annual growth (due to increased competition, economic slowdowns).
  • Most Likely: 20% annual growth (based on current ramp-up rates and market expansion).
  • Optimistic: 25% annual growth (if new models or markets accelerate faster than expected).

This range reflects the uncertainty. Each simulation run will randomly pick a growth rate from within this defined distribution.

Modelling Gross Margins

Gross margin is critical for profitability. Tesla's margins fluctuate based on product mix, production efficiency, and pricing. We could model this as:

  • Pessimistic: 15% (if price cuts are aggressive or production costs rise).
  • Most Likely: 18% (reflecting current trends and efficiency gains).
  • Optimistic: 22% (if new technologies or scale economies significantly reduce costs).

Again, the simulation will draw a margin percentage from this range for each scenario.

Other Critical Inputs

Beyond deliveries and margins, other inputs also require probabilistic ranges:

  • Operating Expenses (OpEx): Modelled as a percentage of revenue. Will Tesla achieve greater operating leverage, or will R&D for new ventures keep OpEx high?
  • Capital Expenditure (CapEx): Essential for growth. This can be modelled as a percentage of revenue or as a growth rate. How much will Tesla invest in new factories and infrastructure?
  • Working Capital Changes: How efficiently will Tesla manage its inventory and receivables?
  • Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): This discount rate reflects the risk of Tesla's future cash flows. While often a single figure, even WACC can be modelled with a small range to account for market fluctuations or changes in capital structure.
  • Terminal Value Growth Rate: The long-term growth rate assumed for cash flows beyond the explicit forecast period. This is a highly sensitive input and benefits from a defined range.

For a detailed breakdown of these inputs and how they feed into a DCF, refer to the valuation section on Screenwich's TSLA page.

Building and Running the Simulation

Once these distributions are defined, the Monte Carlo process begins:

  1. Random Sampling: For each iteration, the simulation randomly selects a value for each input variable (e.g., deliveries growth, gross margin, OpEx percentage) from its defined distribution.
  2. DCF Calculation: These randomly selected inputs are then fed into a standard DCF calculator. A full set of projected free cash flows is generated, and the present value is calculated using the WACC. This yields one intrinsic value estimate.
  3. Repetition: This process is repeated thousands of times. Each run produces a slightly different set of inputs and, consequently, a different intrinsic value.

The result is not a single intrinsic value, but a distribution of thousands of possible intrinsic values. You can see an example of this on Screenwich's Monte Carlo section for TSLA.

Interpreting Results: A Risk-First Approach

The true power of Monte Carlo lies in its output: a probability distribution of intrinsic values. This aligns with the discipline of investors like Charlie Munger and Warren Buffett, who prioritise understanding risk.

Understanding the Distribution

The output will typically be a histogram or density plot showing the frequency of different intrinsic values. This immediately reveals the range of possible outcomes.

Percentiles for Insight

Key percentiles offer crucial insights:

  • 10th Percentile: This represents the intrinsic value below which only 10% of the simulations fell. It's a good proxy for the downside risk or a highly pessimistic scenario.
  • 50th Percentile (Median): This is the middle value, where half the simulations yielded a higher value and half a lower one. It's often considered the most likely intrinsic value.
  • 90th Percentile: This represents the intrinsic value above which only 10% of the simulations fell. It indicates the upside potential or a highly optimistic scenario.

By comparing these percentiles to the current stock price, investors can gauge the potential for loss or gain. For instance, if the 10th percentile is significantly below the current price, it signals substantial downside risk under adverse conditions.

Informing Position Sizing

Bill Ackman often speaks about conviction and sizing. Monte Carlo directly supports this. If the simulation shows a wide distribution of intrinsic values, with a significant probability of the value being below the current price, it suggests a higher risk profile. This might lead an investor to take a smaller position or demand a larger margin of safety.

Conversely, if the distribution is tightly clustered above the current price, with a low probability of downside, it could justify a larger, more confident position. This risk-first approach ensures that potential losses are considered as thoroughly as potential gains.

Practical Application with Screenwich

Screenwich simplifies the application of Monte Carlo simulation for stock analysis. By visiting the TSLA Monte Carlo page, you can visualise the results of these simulations. You can also adjust the underlying assumptions for deliveries, margins, and other variables to see how the intrinsic value distribution changes. This interactive approach helps users build intuition about the drivers of value and the associated risks.

Remember to check the earnings calendar for upcoming announcements. These events often provide new data that can inform and refine your Monte Carlo input distributions, making your valuation models more accurate.

Conclusion

A Monte Carlo simulation is an indispensable tool for robust stock analysis, particularly for growth companies like Tesla. By explicitly modelling uncertainty in key drivers like tsla monte carlo deliveries and margin scenarios, it moves beyond single-point estimates. It provides a comprehensive, probabilistic view of intrinsic value. This risk-first perspective empowers investors to make more informed decisions, understand potential outcomes, and appropriately size their investments, aligning with the prudent principles of seasoned investors.

Screenwich